All articles

Shares vs Property in Australia

An honest comparison of returns, risk, tax and liquidity.

9 min read

This is the great Australian debate. Both build wealth. They do it differently, and the right answer depends on your stage, income, and temperament.

Long-term returns

Over the last 30 years, Australian residential property has returned around 7–8% p.a. including rental yield. The ASX 200 has returned around 9–10% p.a. including dividends. Both beat inflation comfortably; shares have edged ahead, with more volatility.

Where property wins

  • Leverage: banks will lend you 80–90% to buy property. They won't lend you that against shares.
  • Forced saving: a mortgage repayment is hard to skip.
  • Tangible: you live in it or rent it out. Easier emotionally for many people.

Where shares win

  • Liquidity: sell in two clicks. Property sales take months and ~5% in costs.
  • Low entry cost: start with $500, no stamp duty, no LMI, no conveyancer.
  • Diversification: one ETF = hundreds of companies across sectors and countries.
  • No maintenance: no tenants, no leaky taps, no land tax.
The leverage point matters
A 10% gain on a $700,000 property bought with a $140,000 deposit is a 50% return on your money (before costs). Shares can't easily replicate that. This is why so many Australians end up wealthy through property, not because the asset is better, but because the leverage is.

Why not both?

Most financially comfortable Australians end up owning their home (for stability + CGT-free gains) plus an ETF portfolio (for liquid growth and flexibility). It doesn't have to be a fight.

Run the numbers for yourself

Apply this guide to your own situation in seconds.

Compare in the Investment Tracker

Educational and informational purposes only. This does not constitute personal financial advice under Australian law. MyWOS is not a licensed financial adviser and does not hold an AFSL. Consider seeking advice from a licensed professional before making financial decisions.