This is the great Australian debate. Both build wealth. They do it differently, and the right answer depends on your stage, income, and temperament.
Long-term returns
Over the last 30 years, Australian residential property has returned around 7–8% p.a. including rental yield. The ASX 200 has returned around 9–10% p.a. including dividends. Both beat inflation comfortably; shares have edged ahead, with more volatility.
Where property wins
- Leverage: banks will lend you 80–90% to buy property. They won't lend you that against shares.
- Forced saving: a mortgage repayment is hard to skip.
- Tangible: you live in it or rent it out. Easier emotionally for many people.
Where shares win
- Liquidity: sell in two clicks. Property sales take months and ~5% in costs.
- Low entry cost: start with $500, no stamp duty, no LMI, no conveyancer.
- Diversification: one ETF = hundreds of companies across sectors and countries.
- No maintenance: no tenants, no leaky taps, no land tax.
Why not both?
Most financially comfortable Australians end up owning their home (for stability + CGT-free gains) plus an ETF portfolio (for liquid growth and flexibility). It doesn't have to be a fight.